Sunday, August 16, 2026

Module 2-Reflection_Reading Circle 2_Weil's Book Part I

 1.2. Do you agree with Weil’s assessment of the root challenges in education? Is it relevant to a Canadian context?

I agree with Weil’s point about economic inequality and educational inequities as the root challenges in education. As she said, “It’s not just that there is an ‘achievement gap’; it’s that there is an opportunity gap, and we continue to fail to address poverty and racism, …”(p.16). I am working at a secondary school, which is located in a relatively low-income neighborhood. In our school, if a teacher would like to turn their classroom into a thinking classroom, they have to experience the embarrassment of having no whiteboard and no markers. Some of my students who asked to use the washroom were just trying to get food from the Bases Department. I can see that parental instability affects a lot of students’ achievement in my school. Whether in America or in Canada, economic inequality and educational inequities are the root challenges that we are all facing now.

Weil also mentioned “tough love” approaches, discriminatory discipline of young people, and “zero-tolerance” policies. She believed that harsh school disciplinary tactics have a negative impact on education. I agree with it. I think that harsh disciplinary tactics do not help to foster a sense of belonging in students. If students don’t enjoy being in school, they will never be engaged in learning. But I am happy to see that this challenge is not obvious in Canada. I have been working at two to three different secondary schools, and the main values of each school include Kindness. Teachers, administrators, counselors, and support staff are all using positive and restorative discipline. 

There is one point stated by Weil that I don’t quite agree. I may need to do more research on that. She wrote that “…studies show that having teachers who represent a similar background, race, and ethnicity to the majority of their students makes a positive difference for both children and their communities”(p.15). I always believe that a good teacher is defined by their empathy, dedication, and skills, not by their racial background. In my sons’ elementary school, the majority of students are non-white. Most teachers are white. We don’t think that it is an issue. Students like their teachers. Important letters from school are translated into three different languages. Parent representatives in PAC (Parent Advisory Council) can help parents gain a greater understanding of the school. Whether white or non-white teachers, they can all be good teachers or irresponsible teachers. We don’t have to specifically hire a teacher who has a similar background, race, and ethnicity to the majority of their students. Racial background should never be the main reason to hire a teacher.

3. How would a solutionary lens and thinking differ from how some schools and educational models currently support and prepare students? 

Weil reminds us that “today’s world presents our children with unprecedented challenges as well as unprecedented opportunities”, and schools should “ensure that students understand the formidable challenges before them; prepare young people to address these challenges; and engage youth in cultivating their ability and desire to create meaningful solutions to potentially calamitous global problems”(p.17). It requires that not only should all teachers integrate sustainability education into their teaching practice, but also we should have a plan. Elementary school teachers and secondary school teachers should collaborate, and teachers of different subjects in the same school should collaborate. Elementary school teachers could mainly focus on fostering students’ sustainability and environmental awareness, and secondary school teachers could mainly focus on developing students’ ability and desire to create meaningful solutions from each subject’s point of view.

The current educational models used by most public schools in Canada have failed to make students aware of the importance of learning for building an equitable, humane, and sustainable future world. Knowledge from textbooks is still disconnected from the world that they are going to live in 5 or 10 years later.  

4. If you could change anything in education, what would it be? How does your list of changes differ from Weil’s? What’s missing?

I have never thought about changing something in education before. But I am always trying to change something in my math classroom. For example, I am going to integrate a little knowledge of neuroscience into my math teaching practice this coming semester. I was wondering why this interesting and important knowledge about our brain was not introduced to our students. For example, one mini-lesson I am going to talk about is how goals drive our brains. Another mini-lesson I will introduce to my students is Action Creates Motivation. The knowledge about the brain is very helpful for fostering those aspects listed in Weil’s list.

This makes me realize that if each of our teachers starts to design a sustainable learning environment, then the entire education system will be different in a positive way. 

Reference:

Weil, Z. (2016). The world becomes what we teach: Educating a generation of solutionaries (pp. 15-26). Lantern Publishing & Media

No comments:

Post a Comment

Module 6 - Student Voice

  How can you incorporate student perspectives, concerns, and passions into your classroom or school’s approach to sustainabilit...